Sell Silver in Pittsburgh
Jewelry, Bullions, Coins & More...
Immediate Offers.
Trusted for 40+ Years.
Whether you’re clearing out sterling flatware, selling old silver coins, or downsizing a jewelry collection, Broff’s Diamond & Loan offers honest evaluations and same-day payment.
As Pittsburgh’s trusted buyer since 1980, we make the process easy, discreet, and rewarding.
Types of Silver We Buy
Sterling Silver Jewelry
Necklaces, bracelets, rings, and earrings
Mexican silver, Native American silver, artisan-crafted pieces
Broken, tarnished, or mismatched items welcome
Silver Coins & Bullion
American Silver Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, junk silver (pre-1965 U.S. coins)
Silver bars (1oz, 5oz, 10oz, kilo)
Bullion rounds from reputable mints
Note: We do not buy silver-plated items (e.g., marked EPNS or community plate)
🔗 Selling other items too? → View all items we buy
How Our Watch Selling Process Works
Free Silver Evaluation
Transparent Offer
Immediate Payment
If you accept, you’ll leave with immediate payment — no pressure, no consignment delays.
Our fair and transparent process has made us the trusted jewelry silver of choice in the greater Pittsburgh area.
🔗 Learn more about → Our Process
🔗 Learn more about the value of silver → Is Sterling Silver Worth Anything?
Why Sell Silver to Broff’s?
- 40+ years of local trust and expertise
- Transparent pricing based on current silver market rates
- No minimums — we buy one spoon or an entire estate
- We assess both material and maker value (e.g., Tiffany, Georg Jensen)
- Discreet, licensed environment with fair same-day payouts
What Affects Your Silver Payout?
Not all silver is created equal.
At Broff’s, we assess every item carefully to offer you a transparent and accurate payout based on the following factors:
Purity & Type of Silver
Items marked as .999 (fine silver) are worth more than .925 (sterling silver).
We do not accept silver-plated items.
We test and verify purity on-site.
To learn more about silver valuation, you can read here.
Weight
The heavier the piece, the more raw silver it contains, especially in flatware, bullion, or large jewelry items. We pay based on actual silver content, not total weight.
Form (Bullion, Jewelry, Coins etc)
Silver coins and bullion often fetch higher prices due to purity and liquidity.
Broken jewelry or scrap silver is priced for melt value only.
Condition & Rarity
Condition
We look for silver that’s free from major dents, deep scratches, or signs of tampering. Tarnish doesn’t affect value, but structural damage can.
Rarity
Limited-edition coins, bullion with low mintages, or unique silver jewelry designs may be worth more than standard pieces.
Hallmarks & Maker’s Marks
Authentic stamps such as “925”, “Sterling,” or hallmark insignias help verify quality and can influence payout, especially for older or collectible pieces.
Current Market Price of Silver
We base our offers on the live spot price of silver, updated daily. Market fluctuations can affect your payout.
Read our article on silver evaluation for more details
Sell Silver In-Store or From Anywhere
Visit Our Pittsburgh Location
Walk in or schedule a private appointment at our store in the iconic Clark Building in Downtown Pittsburgh for a private, no-pressure evaluation.
Not Local?
No problem — we work with national sellers every day. Start online and ship with our fully insured, prepaid label.
🔗 Start Your Appraisal Process → Get a Free Offer
Silver Selling FAQs
No — we only buy solid silver (sterling .925, coin .900, etc.). Silver-plated items generally have little melt value.
Bring it in or send us a photo — we’ll test it and let you know for free.
Absolutely. Whether you have a single silver coin or a silver ring, we’re happy to evaluate it. Many clients start with one item to see our process — and stay for the fast, fair offers.
🔗 More Frequently Asked Questions → Selling FAQ’s
🔗Unsure whether you want to sell or pawn → Read about the benefits and differences of selling vs pawning
Ready to Sell Your Silver?
Turn your unused or inherited silver into immediate cash — from a buyer Pittsburgh trusts.
Get an Obligation Free Offer
Schedule a Free Consultation
Whether you want to bring items for valuation, or you are looking for an offer to loan on or sell your jewelry, we look forward to meeting you.