Sell Gemstones in Pittsburgh
Sapphires, Rubies, Emeralds & More — Expert Appraisals. Honest Offers.
Whether you’re selling a single gemstone or a full jewelry collection, Broff’s Diamond & Loan offers professional, transparent evaluations and fast, same-day payouts.
With over 40 years of experience in colored stones and estate jewelry, we’re the trusted choice in Pittsburgh for gemstone sellers.
What Types of Gemstones We Buy
We purchase both loose and mounted natural gemstones, including:
Sapphires – Blue, pink, yellow, padparadscha
Rubies – Burmese, Thai, untreated or heated
Emeralds – Colombian, Zambian, faceted or cabochon
Spinel, Tourmaline, Aquamarine, Garnet, Tanzanite
Gemstone jewelry – Rings, earrings, bracelets, and brooches
Estate & vintage pieces – Victorian, Art Deco, mid-century
Note: We currently purchase only natural, untreated or gently treated gemstones of gem-quality.
🔗 Selling other items too? → View all items we buy
How Our Process Works
Free Gem Evaluation
Transparent Offer
Immediate Payment
Our fair and transparent process has made us the trusted jewelry buyer of choice in the greater Pittsburgh area.
- We evaluate both individual stones and jewelry-mounted gems
- Discretion guaranteed for high-value or sentimental pieces
- Immediate cash or wire transfer once you accept
Why Sell Gemstones to Broff’s?
- Trusted by Pittsburgh clients for 40+ years
- In-house gemologists and estate jewelry experts
- Offers based on real-time market demand.
- Understanding of rarity, origin, and collector value
- No auction delays or consignment risk — you get paid today
What Affects Your Gemstone Payout?
Type of Gemstone
Certain gems—like sapphires, rubies, and emeralds—command higher market values than others. Natural, untreated stones are typically worth more.
Gemstone Size
Larger stones usually bring in higher payouts, especially if the quality is consistent throughout.
Color & Clarity
The intensity and purity of color, as well as the visibility of internal flaws or inclusions, directly affect market value.
Cut Quality
A well-cut stone maximizes brilliance and appeal, improving its resale potential and increasing your offer.
Treatment & Enhancement
Gemstones that have been heat-treated, fracture-filled, or dyed may be worth less than untreated, natural stones.
Certification
Having documentation from a trusted gemological lab (like GIA or AGS) helps validate your stone’s characteristics and increases buyer confidence, often leading to better offers.
Market Demand
We factor in current resale demand when pricing your gemstone. Stones with fashionable colors, shapes, or historical popularity may yield better payouts.
Sell Locally or From Anywhere
Visit Our Pittsburgh Location
Walk in or schedule a private appointment at our store in the iconic Clark Building in Downtown Pittsburgh for a private, no-pressure evaluation.
Selling From Out of State?
Start online — we’ll send a secure, prepaid shipping label and make you an offer within 24 hours of receiving your piece.
Gemstone Selling FAQs
At this time, we only purchase natural gemstones.
We can evaluate mounted stones and factor in both the gem and setting value.
We can give an estimate, but we will only be able to give a binding quote once we receive the item via secured shipping.
To start the process, you can send us photos and details using our free quote form.
🔗 More Frequently Asked Questions → Selling FAQ
🔗Unsure whether you want to sell or pawn → Read about the benefits and differences of selling vs pawning
Ready to Sell?
From loose sapphires to antique emerald rings, we make the process respectful, fast, and fair.
Get an Obligation Free Offer
Schedule a Free Consultation
Whether you want to bring items for valuation, or you are looking for an offer to loan on or sell your jewelry, we look forward to meeting you.