Selling gold can be a smart way to get quick cash, but if you’re not careful, you could walk away with far less than your jewelry is worth. Many people make the mistake of rushing to the nearest gold buyer, accepting the first offer they get, or worse—selling their gold jewelry for its melt value without considering its full worth.
We’ve seen it happen countless times. A customer walks in with a beautiful gold bracelet, diamonds sparkling in their setting, only to tell us that another shop offered them a price based on gold weight alone—completely ignoring the diamonds and craftsmanship. Unfortunately, many gold buyers aren’t interested in the full value of a piece, just the raw materials. That’s how sellers lose money – by not getting the best price for their gold and gold jewelry.
Before you make the same mistake, let’s walk through what you need to know to get the best possible price for your gold, jewelry, or luxury watches.
I know my gold, get me an offer…
One of the most common (and costly) mistakes people make when selling gold is accepting the first offer they receive. It’s easy to assume that all gold buyers offer similar prices, but in reality, the difference between one buyer’s offer and another’s can be significant.
We once had a customer bring in a gold necklace with small diamonds embedded in the design. She told us another shop had quoted her based solely on the gold’s weight, completely ignoring the diamonds. When we assessed the piece, we factored in the diamonds, the quality of the craftsmanship, and the demand for that style. As a result, we were able to offer her nearly twice what she was originally quoted.
But not every piece of gold jewelry is worth more than its melt value. Some items—especially those with low-quality stones, heavy wear, or outdated designs—may truly be worth more as scrap. In those cases, the best option is to melt the gold down and sell it for its raw material value. However, only an expert jeweler can accurately determine whether a piece should be valued as jewelry or simply as gold.
Many buyers—especially those who only deal in gold—focus strictly on melt value. They weigh the gold, check its purity, and offer a price based on the current market rate. But what they don’t always tell you is:
The key takeaway? Not all gold jewelry should be melted down—but not all of it is worth more than its gold content, either. That’s why it’s essential to get multiple quotes and work with a knowledgeable jeweler who can assess the true value of what you’re selling.
If you want to maximize the value of your gold, jewelry, or luxury watches, it’s not just about selling—it’s about selling to the right buyer under the right conditions. Many people unknowingly accept less than their items are worth simply because they don’t know how to shop around or what factors impact their payout.
We’ve had customers come to us after selling a piece elsewhere, only to realize they left money on the table. One gentleman sold a diamond-studded gold Cartier bracelet for melt value, only to discover later that he could have received significantly more by selling it as a finished piece. The difference? He went to a gold-only buyer who didn’t specialize in jewelry.
Here’s how to avoid this costly mistake and get the best deal:
Before you sell, take a moment to understand the current gold market. The price of gold fluctuates daily, and while no buyer will offer full spot price (since they need to make a profit), knowing the approximate value per gram or pennyweight gives you a baseline. Websites that track gold prices can give you an idea of what the best price for your gold is, before anyone tries to lowball you.
Never sell to the first place you visit. Take your item to multiple buyers—this includes pawn shops, jewelers, gold refineries, and specialty buyers. Each will have a different way of assessing value, and the price differences can be shocking.
A shop that only deals in gold, for example, will often pay a fair rate for the gold itself but may completely disregard the value of any diamonds, gemstones, or brand significance. A luxury pawn shop, however, understands the full value of your piece, including its setting, craftsmanship, and market demand.
The type of buyer you sell to makes all the difference. Here’s how different buyers operate:
For example, if you have a gold Rolex, selling it based on gold weight alone would be a disaster—the brand and resale demand make it far more valuable as a watch. The same applies to fine jewelry from Tiffany & Co., Cartier, or vintage pieces with unique designs.
Never sell to the first place you visit. Take your item to multiple buyers—this includes pawn shops, jewelers, gold refineries, and specialty buyers. Each will have a different way of assessing value, and the price differences can be shocking.
A shop that only deals in gold, for example, will often pay a fair rate for the gold itself but may completely disregard the value of any diamonds, gemstones, or brand significance. A luxury pawn shop, however, understands the full value of your piece, including its setting, craftsmanship, and market demand.
If your gold jewelry is in good condition, selling it as jewelry rather than scrap metal often brings in significantly more money.
However, not every piece will hold more value as finished jewelry—some items, especially those with heavy wear, low-quality stones, or outdated designs, may be worth more as scrap.
A luxury pawn shop or jewelry buyer who understands the market can assess whether your piece has greater value as a whole rather than just its melt value or if melting it down is truly the best option.
Only an expert can make that distinction, ensuring you get the right price for what you’re selling.
Many gold buyers will pay fairly for gold but undervalue the diamonds or gemstones set in the piece. If you’re selling diamond jewelry, you need a buyer who can properly assess the diamond’s cut, clarity, carat weight, and market desirability.
A common mistake is accepting a flat offer that doesn’t break down the value of the gold vs. the diamonds. A luxury pawn shop specializing in fine jewelry will always separate the two in their valuation, ensuring you get the best deal for both.
Many people assume that polishing their gold jewelry will make it look more appealing and increase their offer. The reality? Cleaning solutions and at-home methods can sometimes damage your jewelry. Harsh chemicals can alter the surface of gold or remove patina on vintage pieces, making them appear less valuable to expert buyers. A professional will clean and assess your jewelry properly without risk.
Before you walk into a shop, have a rough idea of:
This way, if a buyer tries to undervalue your piece, you’ll be better informed to negotiate or walk away. If you’re unsure, a reputable buyer will weigh and test your item in front of you.
If a buyer pressures you into selling quickly, walk away. Some shops use high-pressure tactics, saying, “Gold prices are about to drop—sell now!” or “This offer is only good for today!”
A trustworthy luxury pawn shop will never rush you. They’ll give you time to consider your options and even encourage you to shop around for multiple quotes.
Some disreputable gold buyers use faulty scales or round weights down to offer lower payouts.
A reliable buyer will:
Not all gold is created equal! If you’re selling multiple pieces of different karats (for example, 10k and 18k gold), make sure they’re weighed and valued separately.
Some buyers mix everything together and pay the lowest karat value across the board, costing you money.
Some buyers may only offer store credit or checks instead of cash. Before agreeing to sell, make sure you understand:
A reputable luxury pawn shop will be upfront about payments and offer you cash on the spot if that’s your preference.
Selling gold, jewelry, or luxury watches can be a profitable experience—if you do it right. Avoid common pitfalls, know your jewelry’s worth, and most importantly, choose a buyer who values more than just the metal weight.
At a luxury pawn shop, you’re not just selling gold—you’re selling craftsmanship, diamonds, and market desirability. By avoiding quick-cash traps and understanding how to navigate the process, you’ll walk away with the best possible deal—and no regrets.
More good news is that there are reputable luxury pawn shops that offer flexibility in terms of their selling and pawning process.
So, if you find a luxury pawn shop that you would like to work with, you can work with them either in-person or online.
No worries if you don’t have all the details!
Simply provide the information you do know, and our friendly experts will follow up to help with anything else needed for your quote.
* Field must be completed in order to submit the form.
Sometimes, selling your gold, jewelry, or luxury watches isn’t the right choice, especially if you only need quick cash but want to hold onto your valuable items. If this sounds like you, pawn loans may be a perfect alternative. Let’s explore how they work and why a luxury pawn shop is often the best option for high-end gold and jewelry loans.
A pawn loan is straightforward. Instead of selling your gold or jewelry, you use it as collateral for a short-term loan. Here’s how the process typically works:
The key advantage of pawning is that you don’t lose ownership of your items unless you default on the loan. This gives you time to pay off the loan and get your valuables back, rather than permanently parting with them.
Whether you’re pawning or selling high-end gold, diamonds, or luxury watches, the place you choose to do business matters. While traditional pawn shops can offer quick cash, they may not always give you the best deal for high-value items. Here’s why luxury pawn shops are often the better choice for pawning expensive jewelry and luxury goods:
Pawning can be an ideal solution if you need quick cash but don’t want to part with your treasured jewelry or watches. It gives you a chance to retrieve your items after the loan is paid off, which is a huge benefit if you ever want them back.
For high-value gold and jewelry, opting for a luxury pawn shop ensures you’ll get the best loan terms and a fair evaluation. You can avoid the low-ball offers that might come from general pawn shops and feel confident that your luxury items are in the hands of experts who truly understand their worth.
And, you can do it from the comfort of your home, as some reputable pawnbrokers also offer online options.
Online options are also highly beneficial if you want to make use of the benefit of low pawn interest rates in certain states.
State-by-State Pawn Shop Interest Rates : The Best and Worst Places to Borrow in 2025 The most complete interest comparison guide from A -Z… Pawn loans have long been a
How Pawn Shops Instantly Verify Gold Purity with Expert Precision The Importance of Fast and Accurate Gold Testing You are considering selling some jewelry, a watch, or any other item
Diamond Authentication in Minutes:How Pawn Shops Can Tell If Your Diamond Is Natural, Lab-Grown or Fake How do pawn shops check if a diamond is real? Most people think the
FIND US HERE
715 Liberty Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
TRADING HOURS
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 10:00 AM – 05:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 05:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM – 07:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM – 05:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM – 03:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
GET IN TOUCH
(412) 566-1728
info@broffsdiamonds.com
